Why SEO will ruin the web (or make it better)
With companies like Demand Media (with their sub-par content sites like Ehow.com) and other SEO based content sites, the web is now filled with total nonsense all in the name of money. No longer does Google actually find the best content–instead what is often found are the best optimized sites.
SEO has become a huge game like Monopoly. Google has an algorithm and vast companies work every day to game it. And it is being done over and over again. Instead of taking a second look at poor content sites like Ehow and pushing them down, Google is given a vote of confidence to them. Every time some unknowing person clicks on the url to see one of their pages Google hands them a vote. These are poor pages that are optimized for Google to rank and for us to click. And it works great.
I hate SEO from both a professional online executive perspective and from a users perspective. And I hate that search has become a game that users have to play as well. What also makes SEO and Google’s way of ranking pages frustrating is that many urls basically own search regardless of the topic–which in the end continues to become an embarrassment of riches to that particular site. Look up just about any topic and Wikipedia will show up in the top five nearly every time. If you create a topic today it’ll show up within the next week. And yet other legitimate content sites and pages about the same topic may never show up in search–let alone the first page.
Google’s vote of confidence to sites like Ehow and Wikipedia make trying to grow organically for small mom and pops nearly impossible. Because it only takes a page on one of a few sites to destroy your organic ranking. Their only hope is often resorting to Google AdWords. Bonus for Google. Not so much for the user or small company.
So how does it get fixed? I don’t have an answer to that question. I’m starting to think that directories weren’t such a bad thing. We’ve used directories for centuries and they have held up well. It’s a shame Yahoo dumped them in favor of trying to go after Google. Another option might be a better way to drill down in a search–Google sort of has this with Wonder Wheel–too bad its so hidden. The answer may not be so obvious, but what is obvious is that people are gaming Google. And they are doing it with poor content and making huge profits. Google continues to reward these companies which is surprising. Something has to change. SEO shouldn’t be as much a bigger industry than creating great content.
Read More
